I Am Michael

James Franco

Michael Glatze

Zachary Quinto

Bennett

Emma Roberts

Rebekah Fuller

Daryl Hannah

Deborah

Lesley Ann Warren

Susan

Avan Jogia

Nico

Charlie Carver

Tyler

Devon Graye

Cory

Evie Thompson

Nicole

Leven Rambin

Catherine

Ahna O'Reilly

Actress

Jefferson Mays

Preacher Teacher

Jan Maxwell

Coltry

Nick Rehberger

Adam

Kevin Cahoon

Peter

Blake Lee

Benoit Denizet-Lewis

Jacob Loeb

Teddy

Daniel Polo

Paul

Deidre Goodwin

Cheryl

Blake Young-Fountain

Chris

Vince Jolivette

Pastor Mike

Jenna Leigh Green

Emergency Room Doctor

Amelia Campbell

Judy Shepard

Patrick Page

Bible Teacher

Lance Roberts

Bishop

Eva Augustina Sinotte

Sexy Lady / Eva

Juan Castano

Anthony

Kanoa Goo

Bible Student

Anna Myrha

Buddhist Advisor

Joe Baken

Jeremy

Jaime Cepero

Kid

Ruthie Ann Miles

Kid

Raymond T. Williams

Heart Specialist

Sophie Savides

Crying Girl

Ella Dershowitz

Liberty Student 1

Reema Sampat

Liberty Student 2

Anna Suzuki

Drunk Friend 1

Anni Weisband

Drunk Friend 2

Patrick John Fagan

Paul's Boyfriend

Allie Gallerani

Derica

Laura Ling

News Reporter