Mystery Team

Donald Glover

Jason Rogers

Aubrey Plaza

Kelly Peters

Dominic Dierkes

Charlie Day

D.C. Pierson

Duncan Wheeler

Matt Walsh

Jim

Glenn Kalison

Robert

Peter Saati

Leroy

Kay Cannon

Destiny

Bobby Moynihan

Jordy

John Lutz

Frank

Robbie Sublett

Ricky Appleman

Tom Shillue

Alan McGinty

Ellie Kemper

Jamie

Kevin Dotcom Brown

Bouncer

Dan Eckman

Bread Squeezer

Will Hines

Mr. Stevens

Meggie McFadden

Cathy

Kristopher Kling

Sam

Ben Schwartz

Dougie's Buddy

Ron Simons

Mr. Rogers

Nick Packard

Dougie

Daphne Ciccarelle

Brianna

Gregory Burke

Football Player

Jon Daly

Greg

Joe James

Security Guard (uncredited)