First Reformed

Ethan Hawke

Pastor Ernst Toller

Amanda Seyfried

Mary Mensana

Cedric the Entertainer

Pastor Joel Jeffers

Victoria Hill

Esther

Philip Ettinger

Michael Mensana

Michael Gaston

Edward Balq

Bill Hoag

John Elder

Kristin Villanueva

Nurse Cindy

Ingrid Kullberg-Bendz

Middle-Aged Tourist

Ken Forman

Middle-Aged Tourist

Christopher Dylan White

College Student

Frank Rodriguez

Sheriff

Gary Lee Mahmoud

Doctor

Joseph Anthony Jerez

War Vet in Wheelchair

Sue Jean Kim

Suriya

Miah Issabella Velasquez

Rose

Tyler Bourke

Benny

Natalie Woolams-Torres

Clerk

Van Hansis

Roger

Ramon Nuñez

Jason

Delano Montgomery

Jake

Satchel Eden Bell

Cynthia

Jon Rua

1st Repairman

Otis Edward Cotton

2nd Repairman

Mark Havlis

Pancake House Owner

Erica Fae

1st Secretary

Prudence Wright Holmes

Balq Industries Tour Guide

Ronald Peet

Choir Member

Juliet Schlefer

Choir Member

Elanna White

Choir Member

Olivia Rose Cohenher

Choir Member

Jake Alden-Falconer

Choir Member

Eric Lockley

Choir Member

Krystina Alabado

Choir Member

Dennis Michael Giammetta

Balq's Son (uncredited)

Mahaleia Gray

Jeffers' Daughter (uncredited)